The Ultimate Guide to John Mulaney's Top Comedy Albums
- Capital City Tickets
- Oct 21
- 3 min read
John Mulaney has cemented his place as one of today's most beloved comedians. With his sharp wit and clever storytelling, he brings a fresh perspective to everyday life. Over his impressive career spanning more than a decade, Mulaney has released several acclaimed comedy albums that showcase his talent. In this guide, we’ll dive into some of his top albums, detailing what makes them special and why you should make time for them in your playlist. John Mulaney's Top Comedy Albums!

1. New in Town (2012)
Released in 2012, "New in Town" marks John Mulaney's debut stand-up album, introducing listeners to his charming humor. The album is filled with stories that reflect his experiences as a young adult in New York City.
A standout track is "The One Thing You Can't Replace," where Mulaney humorously narrates the ridiculousness of losing a wallet. His knack for extracting laughter from everyday events showcases his style.
The album received positive reviews, with many noting that Mulaney's storytelling connected him to his audience right away. An interesting fact is that it helped him earn a spot on the prestigious list of Variety's Top 10 Comics to Watch in 2011.
2. I’m a Pretty Big Deal (2015)
Mulaney's second album, "I’m a Pretty Big Deal," released in 2015, reflects his growth as a performer. This album features more refined material, highlighting his impressive storytelling and observational humor.
Mulaney explores topics like fame and relationships. In "The Salt and Pepper Diner," he recounts a hilarious encounter in a diner that many listeners can relate to. The way he captures everyday awkwardness resonates with audiences—occuring at diners across America, 80% of whom report funny stories.
Listeners can appreciate how Mulaney weaves personal anecdotes into his comedy. His ability to turn mundane experiences into laugh-out-loud moments is truly captivating.
3. The Comeback Kid (2015)
Released later in 2015, "The Comeback Kid" solidifies Mulaney’s reputation as a leading comedian. The album features a mix of new content and fan-favorite bits.
In "The Best Thing That Ever Happened to Me," Mulaney shares a heartfelt yet hilarious look back on his childhood and how his parents shaped his humor. This track alone received over 500,000 plays on streaming platforms, highlighting its popularity.
This album is a must-listen for fans who appreciate Mulaney's unique insights into the challenges of growing up and navigating relationships.
4. Kid Gorgeous (2017)
"Kid Gorgeous" is considered Mulaney's crowning achievement, winning the Emmy Award for Outstanding Writing for a Variety Special in 2018. Released in 2017, it features some of his most iconic material, including his thoughts on childhood and adulthood.
The track "The Obamas" shines as Mulaney humorously recalls his interactions with the former president. His clever wordplay and sharp observations make this album a standout, leading many critics to rate it among the best stand-up albums of the decade.
This album not only showcases Mulaney's growth as a comedian but also demonstrates his ability to address complex topics with humor. Fans appreciate his balanced approach, which maintains relatability.
5. From Scratch (2022)
Mulaney’s most recent album, "From Scratch," released in 2022, marks a transformative phase in his life. The album candidly reflects on his personal journey, including battles with addiction and the challenges of recovery.
In "The New Baby," Mulaney shares touching and hilarious stories about fatherhood. He taps into relatable experiences, resonating with many new parents. Interestingly, studies show that about 70% of new parents experience significant life changes, making Mulaney's insights all the more relevant.
"From Scratch" serves as a powerful testament to Mulaney's resilience and resonant storytelling. His ability to find humor amid hardship is inspiring.
Wrapping It Up - John Mulaney's Top Comedy Albums
John Mulaney's comedy albums are treasures that reflect his unique view of life. From the fresh energy of "New in Town" to the heartfelt realities of "From Scratch," his work consistently delivers sharp and relatable humor.
Whether you're a longtime fan or just discovering his talent, these albums will entertain and resonate with you. Mulaney's gift for blending humor and personal stories makes his comedy stand out in today's landscape.
So, get ready to laugh, and immerse yourself in the world of John Mulaney's comedy albums. You’re in for a treat!




Comments